Chapter 6: Messiah or Not?

 


6.1. You probably noticed that I have effectively shrunk, or narrowed, my question. I am no longer trying to evaluate Christianity, or determine whether Jesus was G-d’s son, or whether one can “go to heaven” without believing in Jesus, or whether I should take Jesus as my Savior -- or whatever. Right now, I just want to know whether (or not) Jesus was the Messiah. (Not that I don’t need to answer those other questions, just that I probably need to get a handle on this question first -- before I can effectively address those others. In particular, I don’t think that I can “take Jesus as my Savior” – the ultimate target of Christianity -- unless I can find that the rational and empirical evidence actually support his being the Messiah.)

6.2. And really, I’m just trying to determine to what extent the evidence supports such a thesis…

6.3. While a positive answer to this question seems not nearly so unlikely as positive answers to those other questions I just eschewed, it can still seem highly unlikely to the analytically minded – of which I am clearly one. In order to suspect that Jesus was the prophesied Jewish Messiah, one must first suspect that prophecy is real, that the Old Testament (Hebrew Bible, Tanakh) is prophetic, that it predicts a Messiah (not just a Messianic age), and that there really is such a thing as G-d. These are formidable hurdles for the analytically minded.

6.4. And, while my question does not directly address those other questions just eschewed, it must still address them indirectly, and they still represent formidable hurdles for a positive answer to my direct question. Jesus does seem to say that he is G-d, that the only way to heaven is through him (Jesus) and that those of us who do not believe in him (Jesus), and take him for our Savior, will go to Hell. Would the prophesied Messiah say those things? And that’s just the beginning.

6.5. So I still have my work cut out for me, and I had best get started. (Seems to Work)